The top nine defensive players from all collegiate divisions were recognized with the Rawlings Gold Glove Award, presented by the NFCA, in 2024.
NCAA DI | NCAA DII | NCAA DIII | NAIA | NJCAA DI | NJCAA DII | NJCAA DIII | Cal JC | NWAC
| NCAA DIVISION I |
 |
| P - Libby Baker, Troy University; C - Jocelyn Erickson, FLorida; 1B - Peyton Toto, Cal State Fullerton; 2B - Sydney Kuma, Georgia; 3B - Riley Love, Texas Tech; SS - Paige Sinicki, Oregon; LF - Dakota Kennedy, Arizona; CF - Kendra Falby, Florida; RF - Kate Verhoef, Cal State Fullerton |
|
| NCAA DIVISION II |
 |
| P - Amiee Shanks, Fort Lewis; C - Gracey Brink, Augustana; 1B - Bridgett Morales, Rogers State; 2B - Lawren Hayes, UAH; 3B - Ragan Liles, Wingate; SS - Brenna Lokeinsky, Nova Southeastern; LF - Tristyn Stewart, Wilmington; CF - Kristy Alanis, TAMIU; RF - Brianna Gallagher, Catawba |
|
| NCAA DIVISION III |
 |
| P - Sophia DiCocco, Tufts; C - Emily Stockman, Salisbury; 1B - Ava Khoury, Illinois Wesleyan; 2B - Liz McCaffery, Rowan; 3B - Casey Wissmiller, Illinois Wesleyan; SS - Linzee Leal, Texas Lutheran; LF - Virginia McKinney, WPI; CF - Annie Kay, Texas Lutheran; RF - Lexi Powell, Lynchburg |
|
| NAIA |
 |
| P - Aliyah Rincon, Midland; C - Mackenzie Ming, Madonna; 1B - Jordan Henderson, Southern Oregon; 2B - Carly Oliver, Cumberlands; 3B - Mackenzie Southerland, Coastal Georgia; SS - Central Methodist; LF - Regan Finkbeiner, Madonna; CF - Chelsea Kurtz, Avila; RF - Halle Meyer, Midland |
|
| NJCAA DIVISION I |
 |
| P - Cailyn Heyl, Northwest Florida State; C - Autumn Vessler, Northwest Florida State; 1B - Trinity Allen, McLennan CC; 2B - Addison Wittram, Trinity Valley CC; 3B - Bailey Ast, Crowder; SS - Katia Reyes, McLennan CC; LF - Mickayla Tosch, McLennan CC; CF - Jenna Borkey, Eastern Florida State; RF - Presley Smith, Indian River State |
|
| NJCAA DIVISION II |
 |
| P - Sailor Hall, Kirkwood CC; C - Lexie Griffin, Parkland; 1B - Emma Krueger, Rock Valley (1B); 2B - Avery Sickeri, Frederick CC; 3B - Madelyn Savage, Northeast Mississippi CC; SS - Rachael Schlotter, Kirkwood CC; LF - Elise Jackson, Jones; CF - Madison Moak, Copiah-Lincoln CC; RF - Makynlie Jones, Jones |
|
| NJCAA DIVISION III |
 |
| P - Jenna Plue, Corning CC; C - Avery Martin, North Dakota SCS; 1B - Lily Reed, North Dakota SCS; 2B - Lily Callahan, Corning CC; 3B - Kendyl Moss, North Dakota SCS; Brianna Greenlaw, Corning CC; LF - Skyler Banks, CCC&TI; CF - Sydney Ferguson, CCC&TI; RF - Kayden Craft, Hudson Valley CC |
|
| CAL JC |
 |
| P - Guilianna Clavel, Palomar; C - Morgan Kneubuhler, Mt. San Antonio; 1B - Audrey White, Mt. San Antonio; 2B - Jordan Elias, Fullerton; 3B - Bella Garcia, American River; SS - Xiomei Geluz, Long Beach City; LF - Anahi Pintado, El Camino; CF - Maddie Scott, Palomar; RF - Jazmine Macias, Cerritos |
|
| NWAC |
 |
| P - Bella Carazo, Mt. Hood; C - Shay McDaniel, Treasure Valley; 1B - Skylar Groesbeck, Clackamas; 2B - Leanna Russell, Lower Columbia; 3B - Clare VanSpall, Douglas; SS - Hayden Rockwell - North Idaho; CF - Drew Hashimoto, Walla Walla; RF - Chloe Robinson, Walla Walla |
|
