The top nine defensive players from all collegiate divisions were recognized with the Rawlings Gold Glove Award, presented by the NFCA, in 2025.
NCAA DI | NCAA DII | NCAA DIII | NAIA | NJCAA DI | NJCAA DII | NJCAA DIII | Cal JC | NWAC
| NCAA DIVISION I |
 |
| P - Devyn Netz, Arizona; C - Jocelyn Erickson, Florida; 1B - Arianna Rodi, South Carolina; 2B - Ailana Agbayani, Oklahoma; 3B - Tallen Edwards, Oklahoma State; SS - Koko Wooley, Texas A&M; LF - Elena Heng, Louisiana Tech; CF - Kendra Falby, Florida; RF - Rachel Roupe, Liberty |
|
| NCAA DIVISION II |
 |
| P - Sydney Rader, Missouri Western; C - Sophia Stoddard, Southern Arkansas; 1B - Rachel Novak, Concordia-St. Paul; 2B - Baylee King, Ouachita Baptist; 3B - Kennedy Griego, TAMUI; SS - Madison McDonald, Columbus State; LF - Rylee Lemos, Central Oklahoma; CF - Camryn Quilling, Colorado Christian; RF - Ashley Strick, Hillsdale |
|
| NCAA DIVISION III |
 |
| P - Sophia DiCocco, Tufts; C - Emily Stockman, Salisbury; 1B - Megan Heidelbauer, Simpson; 2B - Riley O'Brien, WPI; 3B - Tavery Ortiz, Texas Lutheran; SS - Jen Kuhn, Illinois Wesleyan; LF - Paige Lathrop, Wisconsin-Eau Claire; CF - Anika Ewert, Bowdoin; RF - Maddie Manes, Brandeis |
|
| NAIA |
 |
| P - Lindsey Shope, Cumberlands; C - Leighanne Eaton, USAO; 1B - Brenna Henry, Arizona Christian; 2B - Lillie Lanham, Mobile; 3B - Ellie Facklam, Evangel; SS - Kaitlyn Wright, Saint Xavier; LF - Regan Finkbeiner, Madonna; CF - Saraha Derling, Southern Oregon; RF - Mackenzie Meister, Grand View |
|
| NJCAA DIVISION I |
 |
| P - Avery Velazquez, Eastern Florida; C - Faith Wharton, Florida SouthWestern; 1B - Trinity Allen, McLennan CC; 2B - Alayna Patrick, Gaston; 3B - Irene Rabasco, Chipola; SS - Kayla Franklin, Chipola; LF - Mickayla Tosch, McLennan; CF - Mariah DeBose, Trinity Valley CC; RF - Skylar Brennan, Florida SouthWestern |
|
| NJCAA DIVISION II |
 |
| P - Amy Bak, Lake-Sumter; C - Jenny Bouthillier, St. Johns River; 1B - Trinity Allen, McLennan CC; 2B - Kinlei Boley, KCKCC; 3B - Jillian Brunton, Louisburg; SS - Kaylee Cary, Iowa Central CC; LF - Emmaleigh Theriot, Pearl River CC; CF - Leo Cline, Frederick CC; RF - Makynlie Jones, Jones |
|
| NJCAA DIVISION III |
 |
| P - Emma Shelton, St. Cloud Tech; C - Caitlyn Dannenfelzer, NDSCS; 1B - Taryn Estes, Caldwell CC; 2B - Rayelle Cooley, NDSCS; 3B - Kendyl Moss, NDSCS; SS - Laila Rodriguez, Patrick & Henry CC; LF - Payton Campbell, Surry CC; CF - Greenly Elliott, Patrick & Henry CC; RF - Sami Petzel, St. Cloud Tech |
|
| CAL JC |
 |
| P - Lexi Ramirez, El Camino; C - Morgan Kneubuhler, Mt. San Antonio; 1B - Zoe Karam, Palomar; 2B - McKenzie Koshi, Orange Coast; 3B - Ava Mendoza, San Mateo; SS - Ayiana Cardenas, Cerritos; LF - Taylor Armstrong, Palomar; CF - Nanea Kyle, Cypress; RF - Analise Memory, Antelope Valley |
|
| NWAC |
 |
| P - Kenzie West, Clackamas; C - Brooklyn Loose, Lower Columbia; 1B - Brooke Herren, Clackamas; 2B - Madison Walker, Mt. Hood; 3B - Jasmyn Lara, Mt. Hood; SS - Aliya Boonsripisal, Edmonds; LF - Serena Hattori, Mt. Hood; CF - Leia Duropan, Columbia Basin; RF - Joelie Eder, Lower Columbia |
|
