2007 Louisville Slugger/NFCA NAIA All-Americans
| First Team | ||
| Pos. | Name | School |
| P | Amy Thomas | California Baptist University |
| C | Jayme Boyer | Oklahoma Baptist University |
| 1B | Dana Dunsmore | Dickinson State University |
| 2B | Lindsay Nuckolls | Biola University |
| 3B | Melissa Peters | Reinhardt University |
| SS | Chantal Millard | California Baptist University |
| DP | Tabitha Foster | Peru State College |
| UT | Kristen Curette | Savannah College of Art & Design |
| OF | Jennifer Perkins | Trevecca Nazarene University |
| OF | Brittany Webb | Belhaven College |
| OF | Amanda Addie | Point Loma Nazarene University |
| At-Large/P | Brittany Johnson | Trevecca Nazarene University |
| At-Large/C | Heather Vaughn | Emmanuel College |
| At-Large/P | Candice Thomas | California Baptist University |
| At-Large/SS | Rachel Bomgren | Vanguard University |
| At-Large/OF | Yaicey Sojo | University of Mobile |
| Second Team | ||
| Pos. | Name | School |
| P | Jennifer Olvera | Vanguard University |
| C | Becky Hartley | Simon Fraser University |
| 1B | Geanie Jenkins | California Baptist University |
| 2B | Maranda Mounce | Lee University |
| 3B | Kate Ward | Iowa Wesleyan College |
| SS | Whitney Godwin | William Penn University |
| DP | Kaila McSpedon | Union College |
| UT | Kaylee Nelson | Evangel University |
| OF | Amerra Kesterson | Biola University |
| OF | Sara Goforth | California Baptist University |
| OF | Caitlin Gidcumb | Olivet Nazarene University |
| At-Large/P | Leigh Baker | Reinhardt College |
| At-Large/P | Meghan Oden | William Penn University |
| At-Large/C | Allison Boeckelman | Point Loma Nazarene University |
| At-Large/SS | Jessica Sanders | Shorter College |
| At-Large/OF | Melanie Matthews | Simon Fraser University |
