2014 NFCA High School All-America Teams
First Team | Second Team | Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Devin Durando | Indian Hills High School (N.J.) |
| Pitcher | Steph Thomas | Immaculate Heart Academy (N.J.) |
| Pitcher | Kiana Millsaps | Alexander Central High School (N.C.) |
| Pitcher | Abby Langkamp | The Woodlands High School (Texas) |
| Catcher | Reagan Hathaway | Olathe Northwest (Kansas) |
| Catcher | Brianna Cassidy | Cajon High School (Calif.) |
| First Base | Caitlin Plocheck | Deer Park High School (Texas) |
| Second Base | Vanessa Shippy | Lake City High School (Idaho) |
| Third Base | Savannah Moore | Washburn Rural High School (Kansas) |
| Shortstop | Kristen Cuyos | Pearland High School (Texas) |
| Outfielder | Emily Neal | Caravel Academy (Del.) |
| Outfielder | Taylor Lockwood | Walker High School (La.) |
| Outfielder | Jessica Adell | Ballard High School (Ky.) |
| Utility | Julia Andersen | Papillion-LaVista High School (Neb.) |
| At-Large (UT) | Rebecca Drake | Monsignor Donovan High School (N.J.) |
| At-Large (SS) | Aubrey Leach | The Woodlands High School (Texas) |
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Tatum Buckley | Masuk High School (Conn.) |
| Pitcher | Allison Stewart | Olathe East High School (Kansas) |
| Pitcher | Kelsee Henry | Washburn Rural High School (Kansas) |
| Pitcher | Brenna Macha | Red Mountain High School (Ariz.) |
| Catcher | Stephanie Abello | Benet Academy (Ill.) |
| Catcher | Maddie McCracken | Olathe North High School (Kansas) |
| First Base | Carly Roleder | Oaks Christian School (Calif.) |
| Second Base | Alexis Mack | Brecksville-Broadview Heights High School (Ohio) |
| Third Base | Madison Shaw | Bridgewater-Raynham High School (Mass.) |
| Shortstop | Savannah Wood | Essex High School (Va.) |
| Outfielder | Mia Baldassari | Morris Knolls High School (N.J.) |
| Outfielder | Kayla Braud | St. Amant High School (La.) |
| Outfielder | Lindsey Stewart | Pearland High School (Texas) |
| Utility | Emily Schaffer | Raritan High School (N.J.) |
| At-Large (DP) | Baily Rhoney | Alexander Central High School (N.C.) |
| At-Large (P) | Miranda Elish | Crown Point High School (Ind.) |
| Position | Name | School |
| At-Large (P) | Payton McBride | Deer Park High School (Texas) |
| At-Large (P) | Caitlyn Brooks | Burbank High School (Calif.) |
| At-Large (P) | Sarah Dawson | Bridgewater-Raynham High School (Mass.) |
| At-Large (C) | Emily Kurkul | Bridgewater-Raynham High School (Mass.) |
| At-Large (1B) | Aidan Falk | Our Lady of Mercy High School (N.Y.) |
| At-Large (2B) | Angelina McGuire | Immaculate Heart Academy (N.J.) |
| At-Large (2B) | Abby Lee | Enid High School (Okla.) |
| At-Large (2B) | Vada Blue Sherrill | Alexander Central High School (N.C.) |
| At-Large (SS) | Ariel Virgulto | Maloney High School (Conn.) |
| At-Large (SS) | Maddie Bullington | Sahuarita High School (Ariz.) |
| At-Large (OF) | Sarah Wilkerson | Mt. Zion High School (Ill.) |
| At-Large (OF) | Katelyn Kelly | North Fort Myers High School (Fla.) |
| At-Large (OF) | Haley Harrison | Deer Park High School (Texas) |
| At-Large (OF) | Danielle Hamilton | Howell High School (Mich.) |
| At-Large (UT) | Lauren Burke | Marist High School (Ore.) |
| At-Large (DP) | Rylie Spell | Pearland High School (Texas) |
