1991 NSCA NJCAA All-America Teams
| First Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| Battery | Nancy Jackson | Central Arizona |
| Battery | Marla Looper | Crowder |
| Battery | Brandi Britton | Central Arizona |
| Battery | Dena Mullins | Central Arizona |
| Infield | Amber Anderson | Lake Michigan |
| Infield | Melissa Brodie | Illinois Central |
| Infield | Linda Mendoza | Ranger |
| Infield | Lisa Wilkins | Central Arizona |
| Outfield | Rhonda Schwebach | Central Arizona |
| Outfield | Karrie Irwin | Illinois Central |
| Outfield | Stephanie Gonzales | Central Arizona |
| Second Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| Battery | Donna McLamb | Louisburg |
| Battery | Halle Headrick | Crowder |
| Battery | Tania Meier | Illinois Central |
| Battery | Kellie Becher | Johnson County |
| Infield | Lisa Oliver | Crowder |
| Infield | April Williams | Crowder |
| Infield |
Chelliee Bennett | Glendale |
| Infield |
Jessica Nolan | Glendale |
| Outfield |
Shanna Cole | Johnson County |
| Outfield | Nikki Sellers | Lake Michigan |
| Outfield | Mindy Jenkins | St. Louis/Meramec |
| Utility | Nicki Coleman |
Lake Michigan |
| Third Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| Battery | Sherry Appledorm | Willimar |
| Battery | Susan Varland | Willimar |
| Battery | Jenny Valana | Wabash Valley |
| Infield | Michelle Granteed | Onondaga |
| Infield | Heather Conway | Central Arizona |
| Infield | Michelle Kalinowski | Erie |
| Infield | Shelly Johnson | Johnson County |
| Outfield | Keesha Estes | Louisburg |
| Outfield | P.J. Black | St. Louis/Meramec |
| Outfield | Jenny Hae | Johnson County |
| Utility | Dana Presley | Crowder |
