NSCA 1991 NAIA All-America Team
| First Team |
||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| At-Large | Stacey Stevens | Emporia State |
| At-Large | Jeri Brummett | Emporia State |
| At-Large | Kerry Clem | Tri State |
| At-Large | Patty Becker | Minnesota-Duluth |
| At-Large | Brenda Dobbelaar | Pacific Lutheran |
| At-Large | Jenny Asbury | Wilmington |
| At-Large | Rochelle Maly | St. Xavier |
| At-Large | Kristie Weed | Lander |
| At-Large | Wendy Castor | IUPUI |
| At-Large | Cathy Hayes | Oklahoma City |
| At-Large | Debbie Hoddevik | Pacific Lutheran |
| At-Large | Jamie Vogel | IUPUI |
